Homestuck.XYZ 2.0

I do think that pre-death, the way she seemed to mostly dodge or not have things like...truly effect her is what gave me that suspicion in the first place. Yes she lost her eye, and she lost her arm, and yes she did (rightfully) get beat and left to bleed to death, but then she GTed and pretty much...

BrobyDDark wrote: ↑

Sun Oct 18, 2020 7:40 pm

can we get double god-tier MeatJohn

The idea sounds simultaneously rediculous, and also like exactly something Homestuck would do.

I wonder if, between Vriska wanting to kick off the Sgrub and Dirk trying to do Sgrub as well, it’ll result in some kind of two-seperate-sessions-are-actually-one-massive-session like the trolls, but on a bigger scale. The only two things I could see impeding this are the lack of communication and t...

Oooo! I get to start one of these. Can't quite throw a chapter in the title, because it isn't considered a new chapter.

https://homestuck2.com/story/344

While not a huge amount of character stuff going on, it's clearly kicking the story up some amount.

That’s certainly fair. Given that they’re naming things by “chapter” would people think a book is a better comparison? I’d like to think a book by chapter 14 might have made a bit more progress. Not that I think this chapter’s feeling like it cut both scenes short would feel good in any context or m...

Holy shit it's been a year and nothing has happened yet. For a frame of reference, the first year of Homestuck ended with Jack: Ascend. So far our first year of Homestuck^2 has had a lot of people sitting around discussing either the events of Homestuck or the fact that Homestuck^2 will eventually ...

Well, to me, not a terrible chapter, it just didn’t feel like... well, a full chapter. It felt more like an excerpt. Don’t get me wrong, I’m still decently invested in what’s going on, and I’m relatively invested in what’s going on, I just feel like... I dunno, I feel like we could have cut the incr...

I'm here mostly for classpect stuff, Karkat as a rebellion leader and maybe robodave and crew, but I'll confess there's a lot going on here I don't have much of a vested interest in. Jane at this point hardly feels like a character to me. She may as well never have gotten the Tiaratop off her head. ...

BrobyDDark wrote: ↑

Tue Aug 25, 2020 9:55 am

All the canon ships are bad (except johnrezi that was pretty cute)

fight me

Just to clarify here, is this all Canon ships *Ever*, or just the canon ships that are sailing? (Like how Dave/Jade isn't currently *really* a working ship, but it did exist at one point).

luigi wrote: ↑

Mon Aug 17, 2020 10:24 pm

I wonder what it means that the reaction to this has been so nothing. Everyone is just like phew it wasnt bad this time.

Personally I expected a lot more reaction, given it seems to be saying Maids or Knights are a passive class.

Well, the most recent chapter of h^2 directly refers to Aradia as a Passive but powerful servant of time. Maid class passive confirmed?

For foreverFlummoxed’s suggestion of knights being passive, I offer this segment of commentary for consideration. "Even though the trolls are at the end of their adventure, the attitude of everyone under Karkat's leadership is pretty much the same as it was when they began: much skepticism and ridic...

Sylphs being an active or passive class is something I’ve been struggling with ever since Aranea, desu. Because Aranea is incredibly self-focused despite claiming to do things for others. A primary example of this is said by Meenah when she says: “MEENAH: araneas deal is MEENAH: what shes doin now i...

Couldn’t you rule Mages as passive pretty easily by that logic? Sollux created Sgrub under the impression it would save the planet (I’ve heard people claim it could be active, as he wanted to leave stop the voices, but It doesn’t seem like that’s part of his goal here. He asks Aradia if she thinks l...

that's just speculative rambling though i got kind of carried away lol Well i think that means that your'e just adhering to the purpose of the thread, you did good. To go a bit into detail about the Knights (since I've had time to think it through) Dave: Utilizes time and fights to protect others, ...

i don't mean to devalue your opinion by saying that "it was intended, you're missing the point," but i think it kind of was? I 100% agree that it's probably intentional. They wanted me to dislike her and it worked lol. Sorta like vriska. Only problem is that unlike vriska I'm a lot less interested....

>hating someone who was raised by a dog and who has no clue how to read subtle social signals :lime: >hating someone who has had decades to learn and understand social signals, or at the very least the basics of "don't mess with other people's relationships" :lime: >hating jade when in both situati...

Given the direct outing of Heir as a Passive class this book, I have high hopes for the next book, and even higher hopes for the book after (since optimistically we’ll hit cascade next book, and act 6 is when they start discussing the system of God-Tiering more openly).

In case anyone here still doesn't have their classpect theories set in stone, The Heir is confirmed as a passive class in the commentary of Book 6, page 306. Could this may mean that another class is going to be revealed as active in a later/the next book? i think this means there are 3 confirmed a...

In case anyone here still doesn't have their classpect theories set in stone, The Heir is confirmed as a passive class in the commentary of Book 6, page 306.